In college writing, the compare and contrast essay is a valuable tool for developing critical thinking and analytical skills. This type of essay requires students to examine two or more subjects, highlighting their similarities and differences in a way that provides deeper insight. Whether comparing different social media platforms, exploring the pros and cons of social networking, or analyzing its impact on different age groups, a well-crafted compare and contrast essay goes beyond simple observation—it builds an argument and engages the reader with thoughtful analysis.

This article will walk you through the process of writing an effective compare and contrast essay, covering key structural approaches, thesis development, and essential writing strategies.

Understanding the Compare and Contrast Essay

A compare and contrast essay explores the relationships between two or more subjects, helping the reader understand them in a new way. This type of analysis is commonly used in academic writing because it encourages deep thinking and the ability to connect ideas.

A successful compare and contrast essay does more than just list similarities and differences—it should present an argument or offer insight into the significance of the comparison.

For example, if you were writing about Instagram and TikTok, a basic comparison would note that both platforms allow users to share short videos. A stronger essay, however, would analyze how their different algorithms influence content visibility, user engagement, and marketing strategies.

Step 1: Developing a Strong Thesis Statement

A thesis statement is the backbone of any essay, setting the tone and direction for the entire piece. In a compare and contrast essay, your thesis should clearly establish the relationship between the subjects and indicate why the comparison matters.

Consider the following thesis examples for a social media compare and contrast essay:

  • Weak thesis: “Instagram and TikTok are both popular social media platforms with similarities and differences.”
    • This is too broad and lacks depth.
  • Stronger thesis: “While Instagram and TikTok both cater to visual content creators, TikTok’s algorithm-driven content discovery fosters rapid virality, whereas Instagram’s focus on curated aesthetics appeals to long-term brand building.”
    • This provides a clear argument and insight into the impact of each platform.

A strong thesis should not only identify what is being compared but also highlight an analytical perspective that guides the reader through the discussion.

Step 2: Choosing an Organizational Structure

There are two primary ways to structure a compare and contrast essay:

1. Block Method (Subject-by-Subject)

In this format, you discuss all aspects of one subject before moving on to the next. This is useful for topics where each subject can be examined in depth before making comparisons.

Example Outline (Comparing Instagram and TikTok):

  • Introduction
  • Instagram: Features, audience, and marketing potential
  • TikTok: Features, audience, and marketing potential
  • Comparison: Major differences and significance
  • Conclusion

This method works well when dealing with complex subjects but requires strong transition sentences to maintain coherence.

2. Point-by-Point Method

This approach discusses specific points of comparison one at a time, alternating between subjects. It’s useful for highlighting key similarities and differences in a more integrated way.

Example Outline (Comparing Instagram and TikTok):

  • Introduction
  • Content Style: Instagram’s curated posts vs. TikTok’s spontaneous videos
  • User Engagement: Instagram’s likes and comments vs. TikTok’s algorithm-driven interaction
  • Marketing Use: Long-term branding on Instagram vs. viral trends on TikTok
  • Conclusion

The point-by-point method allows for a smoother discussion, making it easier to show direct comparisons and contrasts.

Step 3: Supporting Your Analysis with Evidence

A strong compare and contrast essay is grounded in evidence. Instead of making broad claims, back up your points with examples, statistics, expert opinions, or case studies.

For instance, when discussing TikTok’s algorithm, you could cite a study showing how it prioritizes engagement-driven content over follower count. When analyzing Instagram, you might reference statistics on how influencers use its platform for brand partnerships.

To meet academic standards, you must use credible sources. Your essay should include at least two (and up to four) scholarly or reputable sources, properly cited in MLA format (or APA – please consult with your instructor on the type of formatting).

Step 4: Writing and Refining Your Essay

1. Use Clear Transitions

Comparisons should flow logically, so transition words are crucial. Here are some useful ones:

  • For similarities: Similarly, Likewise, Just as, In the same way
  • For differences: However, On the other hand, In contrast, Whereas

2. Maintain a Balanced Approach

A common mistake in compare and contrast essays is focusing too much on one subject while neglecting the other. Ensure both are given equal attention to maintain a fair comparison.

3. Formatting in MLA Style

Your paper should follow MLA guidelines, including:

  • 12-point Times New Roman font
  • Double spacing
  • 1-inch margins
  • Properly formatted in-text citations
  • A Works Cited page

Example MLA in-text citation:
(Turcotte 45)

Example Works Cited entry:
Turcotte, Jason. Social Media and Society: A Critical Introduction. Oxford University Press, 2021.

Writing a compare and contrast essay is more than just listing similarities and differences—it’s about making meaningful connections and drawing insightful conclusions. Whether you’re examining social media platforms, historical events, or literary works, the skills you develop in this type of writing will serve you across disciplines.

Supplemental Information (for instructors to use) is below. This 5th step is present in case students need a reminder to check a rubric of if instructors need a simple rubric for classes. Please cite the source if using this information for something other than the classroom. Students should consult their rubrics provided by their instructors.

Step 5: Reviewing the Rubric and Submitting Your Work

Before submitting your essay, review the grading rubric carefully. Your work will be evaluated based on:
✔️ Thesis and Argument Development (25 points) – Is the thesis clear and well-supported?
✔️ Organization and Coherence (20 points) – Does the essay follow a logical structure?
✔️ Use of Evidence (20 points) – Are sources integrated effectively?
✔️ Grammar and Style (15 points) – Is the writing polished and error-free?
✔️ MLA Formatting (10 points) – Are citations and formatting correct?
✔️ Following Directions (10 points) – Does the essay meet length and source requirements?

By following these guidelines, you’ll be well-prepared to craft a compelling and insightful compare and contrast essay on social media.

Sources Used

  • Understanding the Compare and Contrast Essay: For a comprehensive overview of compare and contrast essays, including their purpose and strategies for writing them effectively, refer to “How to Write a Compare-and-Contrast Essay” by Grammarly. grammarly.com
  • Developing a Strong Thesis Statement: Guidance on crafting a robust thesis for compare and contrast essays can be found in the “Comparing and Contrasting” resource from The Writing Center at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. writingcenter.unc.edu
  • Choosing an Organizational Structure: Detailed explanations of the block and point-by-point methods for organizing compare and contrast essays are provided in “Comparing and Contrasting in an Essay | Tips & Examples” by Scribbr. scribbr.com
  • Supporting Your Analysis with Evidence: For insights into integrating evidence effectively in compare and contrast essays, consult “Writing a Compare and Contrast Essay – Guide & Examples” by CollegeEssay.org. collegeessay.org
  • MLA Formatting: Comprehensive guidelines on MLA formatting, including in-text citations and Works Cited pages, are available in the “MLA Formatting and Style Guide” by Purdue OWL. Purdue Online Writing Lab
Unknown's avatar

Published by Education Universe

The founders of Education Universe have been writing and editing content for business websites, education facilities, and individuals for over ten years. Jackie Jones currently has a Master of Arts in Education (MAE) with an emphasis on education and English from Western Kentucky University (WKU) and Morehead State University, respectively. Jackie also attended the doctoral program at WKU, which was focused on organizational leadership, so she is well-versed in education. Jackie's background in education, including curriculum development, information technology, writing, and editing services (for individuals and businesses), combined with her professional and caring attitude is the reason that people work with her. Jackie is building her "Writing Made Easy" Youtube channel to help support high school and college-level writers. Other contractors help with tutoring, writing, editing, and contributing to educational information on the Education Universe website. The people at Education Universe believe in serving others in a way that will empower them to pursue great things in life and that a great mentor can make all the difference. To contact us, use our contact page.

Leave a comment